KarmaX said:
I am sick of people obnoxiously abusing this system. I am honestly starting to believe this list should be abolished and the system should be retired, imo. Hardly ANYONE is using it properly.
I hate it too. I can't stand when artists put themselves on DNP, especially for petty reasons like this. The only reason I can maybe respect is wanting to dissociate from your NSFW or fetish works, and even then I hate it. But while the other reasons suck, they're not an abuse of the system. In fact, it's
exactly what the system is for.
Boorus like these operate in a legal grey area. What they do is
not fair use. Unless the artist gives explicit permission to upload their work here, doing so
is copyright infringement. The
reason doesn't matter, an artist has the right to choose where their works are copied to.
The DNP system is a compromise. The site asks for forgiveness rather than permission. They freely allow users to upload everything, but agree to takedown images an artist doesn't want up. In this way they avoid DMCA takedowns, which artists have every right to do.
In other words, it doesn't matter if the artist wants to stop piracy, if they've decided to nuke all their artwork because they hate themselves, or if they're throwing a bitchfit at the admins. No matter the reason, they still have the right to take their stuff. (Artists: please don't though because it seriously sucks).