Xelrog said: However this resolves, it would probably be wise to update the rules with clear and specific language to avoid this confusion in the future. Ie, is "solid color" defined as literally a single solid color, or as including gradients that are deemed not varied enough?
The rule concerns utility. If the eyes are a gradient that's so indistinguishable from a solid color that they may be a solid color, then it will be considered a solid color.
That said, this one is not a problem. The color is not solid, even if a little subtle.
However this resolves, it would probably be wise to update the rules with clear and specific language to avoid this confusion in the future. Ie, is "solid color" defined as literally a single solid color, or as including gradients that are deemed not varied enough?
If something's low quality, it's low quality. Getting caught up in the concern of whether or not some pixels are imperceptibly different is silly. This, to me, looks low quality.
Xelrog said: Is there a final word from mods on this one? I have another version. It'd just be a shame to lose the favorites and such.
I'll gladly remove my flag if the Moderators come and say that I'm incorrect. I'm one to freely admit when I'm wrong, but only if authority stacks proof against me. To me (and a few others it seems) the eyes are solid color, not gradient. It might be that the monitors of the other complainers are too small of a resolution to be able to show them the gradient, but at 1366x768 (My monitor's resolution), I'd expect to be able to see a noticeable degree with the gradient if there was one, especially since I do actually have an artist's eye. It's not that I can't see it, it's that I believe it's too subtle of a gradient for most people who'd look at it to be able to see it themselves. If a moderator says that it's noticeable enough, as I said, I'll revoke my flag, and stick out my white one instead.
Date Feb 7, 2017UserHypnoticLunaticRating QuestionableScore84(vote up)
The_Gearheart said: My first post here on the hub, and also my first manip! Enjoy everyone. While I'll never play LoL... I'm finding Tristana impossibly attractive.
The_Gearheart said: My first post here on the hub, and also my first manip! Enjoy everyone. While I'll never play LoL... I'm finding Tristana impossibly attractive.
You're not the only one in reality, but for now I'll stick with Kat, Ashe, MF and Lux :P
kirux said: The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
Not really, The ichor from the grail enhances negative traits while suppressing positive ones. If you compare Gilgamesh (Archer) vs Kid Gilgamesh and Gilgamesh (Caster) you can see an amazing difference in all three personalities. Archer Gil is an egocentric, dismissive, callous bigot, kid gil is a nice kid and hates his future self, and Caster Gil is probably the Broest character in Grand Order.
Saber Alter is really a Mean, spiteful Saber, since her sense of manners and morals are suppressed to let her frustration and lothing come t the fore, which is why her Charisma skill takes a 1.5 rank drop from A to B-. She is a shit heel.
kirux said: The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
Not really what I was getting at with the cheesy comment. Personally I like Jeanne Alter the most in F/GO after all.
It's more just about how Gilles took Jeanne's shape, slapped a paint job on and inserted a new personality and called it a day. Saber Alter is supposedly an aspect of Arturia brought out by the grail mud, but there's no Alter personality inside Jeanne for the grail to bring out in her case.
kareshy said: It's fairly explicit that none of what makes Jeanne Alter different actually existed in her normally. It's about the same as a cheesy Sonic OC; Gilles wished for a Jeanne that was outraged at her treatment and would seek revenge on France and England, the grail granted that wish by creating a new version of her.
The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
DrgnmastrAlex said: Said insane man is Gilles De Rais, who fought alongside her, and has a corrupt Caster version (that you see in Fate/Zero) and a more knightly Sabre version. The insane Caster version was obsessed with Jane and managed to create the Dragon Witch Jeanne from his delusions. So it's arguable that Jalter is both a fake and a corrupt version of Jeanne, according to one closest to her.
It's fairly explicit that none of what makes Jeanne Alter different actually existed in her normally. It's about the same as a cheesy Sonic OC; Gilles wished for a Jeanne that was outraged at her treatment and would seek revenge on France and England, the grail granted that wish by creating a new version of her.
Vanndril
2017-02-11 08:46:06>> #155618
However this resolves, it would probably be wise to update the rules with clear and specific language to avoid this confusion in the future. Ie, is "solid color" defined as literally a single solid color, or as including gradients that are deemed not varied enough?
The rule concerns utility. If the eyes are a gradient that's so indistinguishable from a solid color that they may be a solid color, then it will be considered a solid color.
That said, this one is not a problem. The color is not solid, even if a little subtle.
Xelrog
2017-02-10 06:48:35>> #155387
Anon_3.141
2017-02-10 05:34:55>> #155378
akaece
2017-02-09 07:35:45>> #155212
Anon_3.141
2017-02-08 23:09:45>> #155125
Is there a final word from mods on this one? I have another version. It'd just be a shame to lose the favorites and such.
I'll gladly remove my flag if the Moderators come and say that I'm incorrect. I'm one to freely admit when I'm wrong, but only if authority stacks proof against me. To me (and a few others it seems) the eyes are solid color, not gradient. It might be that the monitors of the other complainers are too small of a resolution to be able to show them the gradient, but at 1366x768 (My monitor's resolution), I'd expect to be able to see a noticeable degree with the gradient if there was one, especially since I do actually have an artist's eye. It's not that I can't see it, it's that I believe it's too subtle of a gradient for most people who'd look at it to be able to see it themselves. If a moderator says that it's noticeable enough, as I said, I'll revoke my flag, and stick out my white one instead.
reader8363
2017-02-07 06:54:37>> #154912
pokemongirl
2017-02-07 21:02:01>> #155000
anon9
2017-02-07 12:15:45>> #154963
My first post here on the hub, and also my first manip! Enjoy everyone. While I'll never play LoL... I'm finding Tristana impossibly attractive.
You and me both buddy.
Mister Vi
2017-02-07 09:11:14>> #154945
Anon_3.141
2017-02-07 07:32:51>> #154921
You're adorable.
(Sung to the tune of that "I made you/it out of clay" song.)
asaola
2017-02-07 07:27:40>> #154920
My first post here on the hub, and also my first manip! Enjoy everyone. While I'll never play LoL... I'm finding Tristana impossibly attractive.
You're not the only one in reality, but for now I'll stick with Kat, Ashe, MF and Lux :P
LustyHypnosis
2018-01-28 03:43:52>> #230546
Sure looks like it, as if that's a bad thing.
Nah, it’s a good thing because the capturers (is that a word?) have a free slave!
xXxGingeSlut357xXx
2017-02-09 16:53:00>> #155274
Is this before and after? Like, they found her out in the wilderness and made her a subject?
Yup.
Trishbot
2017-02-07 18:44:21>> #154991
Is this before and after? Like, they found her out in the wilderness and made her a subject?
Sure looks like it, as if that's a bad thing.
Xelrog
2017-02-07 07:01:04>> #154916
DouDile
2017-02-07 05:31:42>> #154903
Master_Bates
2017-02-07 12:28:25>> #154964
Was not me. I got it in the Gravity Falls booru. had no source.
This appears to be the original source: inuyuru.tumblr.com/post/1...meforrent-done-during-the
Orphaen
2017-02-07 07:00:09>> #154915
Hypno-man
2017-02-07 06:39:20>> #154909
pokemongirl
2017-02-07 04:54:08>> #154897
pineapple
2017-02-07 02:34:32>> #154875
Pinkanator
2017-02-07 02:17:08>> #154873
sanicthehedgehog
2017-02-07 17:01:27>> #154984
I already said this but, she's from the short-lived comic series.
O
Pinkanator
2017-02-07 02:11:19>> #154871
I don't remember her from the movie
I already said this but, she's from the short-lived comic series.
sanicthehedgehog
2017-02-07 02:02:35>> #154869
Evilunicorn
2017-02-14 19:07:53>> #156246
Link
2017-02-08 07:43:33>> #155074
pokemongirl
2017-02-07 04:51:47>> #154896
Welly well well! Very nice! I knew these two would look good together!
Excellent work zorro! And very nice commission idea Erika!
Mmmmm~ looks like a fun time *giggles*
Pinkanator
2017-02-07 02:12:19>> #154872
mariosonicfan
2017-02-06 23:44:24>> #154856
Excellent work zorro! And very nice commission idea Erika!
pokemongirl
2017-02-06 21:38:29>> #154827
cdyoung
2017-02-07 10:31:39>> #154951
The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
Not really, The ichor from the grail enhances negative traits while suppressing positive ones. If you compare Gilgamesh (Archer) vs Kid Gilgamesh and Gilgamesh (Caster) you can see an amazing difference in all three personalities. Archer Gil is an egocentric, dismissive, callous bigot, kid gil is a nice kid and hates his future self, and Caster Gil is probably the Broest character in Grand Order.
Saber Alter is really a Mean, spiteful Saber, since her sense of manners and morals are suppressed to let her frustration and lothing come t the fore, which is why her Charisma skill takes a 1.5 rank drop from A to B-. She is a shit heel.
M1NDFL4Y3R
2017-02-07 06:55:28>> #154913
kareshy
2017-02-07 02:08:52>> #154870
The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
Not really what I was getting at with the cheesy comment. Personally I like Jeanne Alter the most in F/GO after all.
It's more just about how Gilles took Jeanne's shape, slapped a paint job on and inserted a new personality and called it a day. Saber Alter is supposedly an aspect of Arturia brought out by the grail mud, but there's no Alter personality inside Jeanne for the grail to bring out in her case.
kirux
2017-02-07 00:52:18>> #154862
It's fairly explicit that none of what makes Jeanne Alter different actually existed in her normally. It's about the same as a cheesy Sonic OC; Gilles wished for a Jeanne that was outraged at her treatment and would seek revenge on France and England, the grail granted that wish by creating a new version of her.
The same could be said of Saber Alter on how cheesy it is. If that's our preferred word here.
kareshy
2017-02-07 00:50:31>> #154861
Said insane man is Gilles De Rais, who fought alongside her, and has a corrupt Caster version (that you see in Fate/Zero) and a more knightly Sabre version. The insane Caster version was obsessed with Jane and managed to create the Dragon Witch Jeanne from his delusions. So it's arguable that Jalter is both a fake and a corrupt version of Jeanne, according to one closest to her.
It's fairly explicit that none of what makes Jeanne Alter different actually existed in her normally. It's about the same as a cheesy Sonic OC; Gilles wished for a Jeanne that was outraged at her treatment and would seek revenge on France and England, the grail granted that wish by creating a new version of her.